Wednesday, 8 June 2011


Whatever happens to Greece in the coming years, you can bet your bottom dollar one thing will not survive as we currently know it: the Greek Constitution. It's a cracking read; I thoroughly recommend it. Sadly, the political elite never had much respect for it and the Sainted People are already of a mind to wipe their collective ass with it; especially the bits about private property.

Amazingly, there is something very ordinary about the life of the Greek Consitution: it is conforming almost exactly to the historical patterns of constitutional survival.

How do I know? I know due to the amazing work of Tom Ginsburg of the University of Chicago. He's engaged in a massive project trying to figure out why some constitutions live longer than others. You can check out a draft of his report on this project here. The basic facts are these: the average constitution lives for about 17 years, but there are two particular rough patches: the 10-year and the 35-year itch. The 10-year threshold was crossed back in '85, and sure enough in '86 the Constitution was first amended to completely remove the last of the remaining powers of the President of the Republic. Well, guys, the Constitution turned 35 last year: the single most dangerous year in a Constitution's life. Since then, we haven't been sovereign and there's been a lot of legal stuff to get through so hey. One more year.

Now you might argue that this statporn is a little too slavish. There is no such thing as determinism and magic numbers in politics. I agree. But it is also true that Constitutions can outlive the conditions that first gave birth to them. Maybe the trends in constitutional survival are simply an indication of how quickly the political reality comes out of sync with institutions that once served it reasonably well. Stick with me on this one if you still disagree cause it gets interesting.

Turns out that, according to Ginsburg, there are factors that you can watch to see whether I'm on the right track. Turn to page 59 for a list of precipitating factors (literally, factors likely to tip you over the edge).
  • Losing a war (which some people think we have in a way, as we have lost sovereignty) 
  • Widespread constitutional change globally 
  • Lack of constitutional change in neighbouring countries
  • Transition to a more authoritarian government
  • Coups
  • Lack of change of the effective executive (in our case, few or no consecutive changes of Prime Minister) 
  • Conflict (this is a general term including incidents such as anti-government strikes on the lower end of the scale and guerilla warfare somewhere on the higher end). 
So if you're a constitutional lawyer and you wake up one day to find that Yorgo is still clinging on despite open rebellion from his own party and the Socialists seem unlikely to be overthrown, if you find that people around the world but *not* our immediate neighbours are overthrowing their governments or forcing them to change the constitution (chances are you have), if you find that the army has taken over, or some leftist nutcase who sets the police or some rabid People's Militia after everyone he/she doesn't like, or if you find that the Government has started to really crack down on civil liberties, well, get your best MontBlanc out.

Once you've got these factors stacked up against the hapless Constitution, there are a few characteristics of the Constitution itself that can help tip it over that much faster. It's important to take note of these as our new constitution will have to steer clear of them too:
  • If it was ratified by a public or constitutional convention, but under the auspices of an undemocratic regime (nope)
  • If it was not ratified by a public or constitutional convention at all (nope) 
  • If the country is acknowledged as being ethnically heterogenous (getting there)
  • If the country is poor or underdeveloped (nope)
  • If the constitution was not meant to make the system more democratic (nope)
  • If the constitution is, by design, hard to review or amend (check). This is a very strong effect
  • If the constitution is a short text that does not make allowance for different political scenaria or occurences (sort of; it is long, don't know about complexity; but this is one more reason to be suspicious of the half-baked indignado bullshit hatched over at Syntagma)
This is a tricky one because it suggests that structurally the Greek constitution is probably not built to last. The precipitating factors are mostly and so are many of the structural factors, but not all of them. This means, to my mind, that it will be tricky amending the constitution, and even then only specific things will be changed; we won't get a wholesale review.

Now there are many reasons why Constitutions shouldn't live forever, and they are reviewed quite thoroughly by Ginsburg. But there is one overriding imperative from where I sit which advocates in favour of a long-lived new Constitution: Foreign Direct Investment doesn't really take off until a Constitution has passed its 35-year test, perhaps not coincidentally.

A constitutional.dividend 35 years from now may not sound like much but it just might be factored in by bond markets; some in Greece are secretly hoping to borrow bilaterally from China for a few years as well, and the central planners in Beijing will sure appreciate some staying power in our institutions if they're going to take a punt.

Good luck guys!

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please remember that I am not notified of any comments and will not respond via comments.

Try to keep your criticism constructive and if you don't like something, do tell me how to fix it. If I use any of your suggestions, you will be duly credited.

Although I'm happy to entertain criticism of myself in the comments section, I will not tolerate hate speech. You will be given a written warning and after that I will delete further offending comments.

I will also delete any comments that are clearly randomly generated by third parties for their own promotion.

Occasionally, your comments may land in the spam box, which may cause them to appear with a slight delay as I have to approve them myself.

Thanks in advance for your kind words... and your trolling, if you are so inclined.